6 Signs Your Cleaning Contractor Is Underperforming (And What to Do About It)

Poor cleaning might not be spotted straight away. It can start with the same corners being missed each week, the same complaint being raised a couple of times, and the same explanation being offered. It might have been a problem for months before anyone takes action. 

This article explores six signs to watch out for, what each one indicates, and how to put it right.

Key Insights: What are the signs of poor cleaning?

  • The same areas are missed every week
  • Standards drop whenever your usual cleaner is away
  • Nobody can tell you when a periodic task was last done
  • The same complaint keeps coming back
  • You never see an audit, or the score never changes
  • You see a different face on site every month.

6 Signs of Poor Cleaning

1. The Same Areas Are Missed Every Week

What you notice: edges and corners, behind and under furniture, high-level surfaces, the parts of a washroom you have to crouch to see.

What it usually means: there is probably no written specification, or there is one that nobody is working from. Consistent misses are usually a problem with the systems, rather than laziness.

What to do: ask to see the specification. If it doesn’t exist, that is the first thing to fix, and it is usually fixable without changing your supplier.

2. Standards Drop When Your Usual Cleaner Is Away

What you notice: a noticeably worse clean during holidays or sickness.

What it usually means: the cover is being handled reactively, often through agency staff who have never seen your building and have no induction to it.

What to do: ask how absence cover works, who provides it, and whether cover staff are inducted at your site. At MCS Cleaning, our cover is handled internally by directly employed staff rather than agency temps.

3. Nobody Can Tell You When a Periodic Task Was Last Done

What you notice: you ask when the carpets were last extracted, or the high-level dusting was done, and nobody knows.

What it usually means: daily tasks are happening, but periodic ones quietly are not. This is the single most common form of slow decline, because the daily clean still looks fine.

What to do: ask for a dated record of periodic tasks. If one cannot be produced, assume the work has not been done.

4. The Same Complaint Keeps Coming Back

What you notice: you raise something, it gets fixed, and six weeks later, it is back.

What it usually means: issues are being handled as one-off favours rather than changes to the routine. Nothing has been written down, so nothing has actually changed.

What to do: when you raise something, ask what will change in the schedule to stop it recurring, and get the answer in writing.

5. You Never See an Audit, or the Score Never Changes

What you notice: no audit at all, or one that scores the same every month, regardless of what the building looks like.

What it usually means: either nobody is checking, or the audit is a formality, since a real audit would find issues.

What to do: ask for the last three audits. Flat scores across three months are a bigger warning sign than a low score.

6. You See a Different Face on Site Every Month

What you notice: constant new starters, frequent introductions, repeated retraining.

What it usually means: high staff turnover, which is often the root cause behind the other five signs. Every new cleaner has to learn the building, and on a site with constant turnover, that learning never ends.

What to do: ask about turnover on your site specifically, and whether cleaners are directly employed or supplied. 

Related reading: How to Choose a Cleaning Company for Your Business

What Is a Cleaning Audit, and What Should It Include?

A cleaning audit is a scored inspection of a building against its written cleaning specification, carried out on a set frequency and recorded.

A cleaning audit should include:

  • Scores against the specification, not against general impression
  • A date and a named auditor
  • Which areas were sampled
  • Findings with an owner and a deadline, not just a score
  • A trend line over time, so improvement or decline is visible.

An audit with no actions attached is just a report, and nothing changes because nothing was asked to change.

Related reading: The UK Commercial Cleaning Standards Guide

Which Cleaning KPIs Actually Matter?

The cleaning KPIs worth tracking are:

KPIWhat it tells youWhat good looks like
Audit score against specificationWhether the agreed standard is being metConsistent, with any variance explained
Periodic task completion Whether the non-daily work is happeningEvery task is evidenced with a date.
Repeat complaint rateWhether problems are being fixed or patchedRepeat complaints are trending towards zero.
Response time to reported issuesWhether the contractor is reachable and reactiveAgreed in the contract, and met
Staff turnover on your siteWhether the same people are cleaning your buildingLow and stable
Cover arrangements usedHow absence is really handledPlanned, named, inducted.

A KPI that measures activity rather than outcomes can look healthy even as the building gets dirtier. Hours delivered, visits completed, and staff attendance all tell you the contractor turned up, but not whether the building is clean.

What to Do If Your Cleaning Contractor Is Underperforming

  1. Check if a specification exists. You cannot hold anyone to a standard that was never agreed on.
  2. Raise it formally, with evidence such as dates, photographs, and specific areas. 
  3. Agree on an improvement plan with dates, an owner, and a defined review point.
  4. Check your contract. Notice periods, break clauses, and review rights vary, so read what you signed before making any assumptions.
  5. Retender if nothing changes. Most contracts recover at step three, and those that don’t usually didn’t specify properly at step one.

Signs of Poor Cleaning FAQs

What are the signs of poor cleaning? 

Signs of poor cleaning include repeatedly missed areas, declining standards during absences, unrecorded periodic tasks, recurring complaints, infrequent or absent audits, and a different cleaner on-site each month. Most come down to a missing specification, no records, or high turnover, which tends to drive the rest. 

What is a cleaning audit? 

A cleaning audit is a scored inspection of a building against its written cleaning specification. It should be carried out at an agreed frequency, be dated, attributed to a named auditor, and recorded so performance can be tracked over time. It should also include actions with clearly defined owners and deadlines.

How often should a cleaning audit be carried out? 

It depends on the building and the risk involved. Monthly is common for commercial contracts, and quarterly can be enough for low-traffic sites. Healthcare is the exception because the National Standards of Healthcare Cleanliness 2025 set audit frequencies by functional risk category, from weekly for the highest-risk areas down to annually for the lowest. Whatever the interval, it should be written into the contract.

What cleaning KPIs should I measure? 

Cleaning KPIs should measure outcomes and quality. Useful metrics include audit scores against the specification, periodic task completion rates, repeat complaint rates, issue response times, and site staff turnover. Tracking hours delivered or staff attendance is less useful, as a contractor can meet both while the building cleanliness steadily declines.

Can I hold my cleaning contractor to a standard that is not in the contract? 

Baseline legal duties apply regardless of what the contract says. Under the Workplace (Health, Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1992, an employer must keep floors, walls, ceilings and furniture sufficiently clean and manage waste. Anything beyond that baseline needs to be written into the specification if you want to enforce it.

How do I raise poor cleaning performance with my contractor? 

Raise it formally and in writing, with evidence. Dates, photographs and specific areas are more useful than a general complaint about standards slipping. Ask what will change in the schedule to stop the problem recurring, agree on a review point, and keep a record of what was agreed.

Should I fix the relationship or change the contractor? 

Try to fix it first. Most underperforming contracts recover once there is a clear specification and a record of what has been done. Changing suppliers is worth doing when performance does not improve after a fair, documented attempt, or when the contractor cannot produce the basics when asked.

If the signs above look familiar, the place to start is a clear specification and a way to check that it is being met. MCS Cleaning builds both into every contract, with directly employed cleaners, internal absence cover and regular quality audits. We clean offices, schools, warehouses and healthcare settings across the East Midlands, Leicestershire and Berkshire.

GET A FREE QUOTE

CONTACT US

Midlands and Surrounding

Tel: 01530 382006

Unit 15
The Courtyard Stenson Road
Coalville
Leicestershire
LE67 4JP

Berkshire and Surrounding

Tel: 0118 3049827

Unit 12 Space Business Centre
Molly Millars Lane
Wokingham
Berkshire
RG41 2PQ

SOCIAL MEDIA

Follow us on Social Media

iso certified logos
MCS Cleaning 2023 Global Excellence Award Winner